Chapter 14

Chapter 142,239 wordsCompleted

Hester sends Pearl to the seashore where the child dances along the wet sand, peers into a tide‑pool, and imagines a mirror‑image maid inviting her to step into the water. While Pearl plays, Hester meets Roger Chillingworth, who has taken up the role of the town physician. Chillingworth rises from a stooped posture and initiates a conversation about a recent magistrate’s discussion of possibly removing Hester’s scarlet letter. Hester replies that the letter will fall away only if she herself becomes worthy, and she rebuffs his suggestion to keep it as ornament.

During their dialogue Hester notes a striking change in Chillingworth’s demeanor: his scholarly calm has been replaced by a fierce, guarded look, intermittent flashes of red light in his eyes, and a smile that betrays a dark inner fire. Chillingworth admits that he has spent seven years analyzing and tormenting a “heart full of torture” – the minister – and that his careful medical care has kept the minister alive only to continue the suffering. He boasts that the minister’s life would have been extinguished within two years without his intervention, and declares that he has been the minister’s “fiend” and the source of his perpetual misery.

The conversation turns to the minister’s hidden guilt. Chillingworth describes the minister as constantly aware of an unseen, evil presence (himself) that haunts his thoughts, dreams, and conscience. He boasts that his own evil has become a “devil’s office” and that he cannot pardon the minister, for his old faith now tells him that the torment is a necessary dark fate. Hester, anguished, blames herself for allowing Chillingworth’s revenge, and Chillingworth responds that the scarlet letter itself has already avenged him.

After an intense exchange in which Hester accuses Chillingworth of having caused the minister’s ongoing torment and Chillingworth affirms his role as the minister’s tormentor, Chillingworth places a finger on the scarlet “A,” declares that it has avenged him, and states that there is no further good for any of them, including Pearl. He then calmly resumes his work, rising and moving away to continue gathering herbs, leaving Hester stunned and reflective.