CHAPTER VIII
Victor, his father and the rest of the Frankenstein family attend the trial of Justine Moritz, the family maid accused of killing the “smiling babe,” Victor’s younger brother William, and of a second unspecified crime. Victor perceives the proceeding as a mockery of justice, knowing that the true murderer is the Creature he created. The prosecution presents circumstantial evidence, most notably a portrait found in Justine’s pocket that Elizabeth recognizes as the one she placed around William’s neck.
Justine appears calm yet deeply distressed. She testifies that she was out searching for the child on the night of the murder, was questioned by a market‑woman, and spent a sleepless night in a barn near Geneva. She cannot explain how the portrait came to be in her pocket and insists on her innocence. Several witnesses speak kindly of her character, but fear of the crime prevents them from giving strong testimony.
Elizabeth Lavenza rises to defend Justine, describing her long record of kindness, her care for Madame Frankenstein and other family members, and her “perfect innocence.” Her heartfelt appeal moves the audience but does not sway the judges. The court, relying on the portrait as “glaring evidence,” finds Justine guilty, and the magistrate notes that she has “confessed,” a statement that horrifies Victor because he knows she could not have killed William.
At Elizabeth’s urging, Victor visits the condemned Justine in her cell. She weeps, throws herself at Elizabeth’s feet, and confesses that she lied to obtain absolution, not because she is guilty. She expresses resignation, asks for forgiveness, and comforts Elizabeth before her execution. Victor remains in a corner, overwhelmed by remorse, describing a “worm of remorse” alive in his bosom.
Justine is executed the next day despite Elizabeth’s tears and Victor’s desperate pleas. Victor reflects that his “thrice‑accursed hands” have caused the deaths of William and Justine, and that his sorrow will echo in further tragedies for his family, especially Elizabeth. The chapter intensifies the novel’s themes of responsibility and the far‑reaching consequences of Victor’s secret scientific transgression.